|
Selecting Corn Hybrids
There is no "perfect hybrid" for every situation. Each hybrid
has a particular range of soil types, fertility levels, production practices,
geographical areas and weather conditions which maximize performance. The
difference in performance response to different corn growing environments from
one hybrid to another is due to the genetic families used to develop the hybrid.
At CROPLAN GENETICS, we market superior-performing corn hybrids with the hybrid
placement and management information to take advantage of that performance
potential based on hybrid genetics. The RATE Plot program at CROPLAN GENETICS
gathers this information.
The RATE Plot program is a system of corn hybrid and soybean
variety yield trials. It includes information from approximately 1000 corn and
600 soybean plots planted by farmers using field-size planting and harvesting
equipment, not small research-specific two-row equipment favoring tall hybrids.
As precision farming increases in popularity, this database will become even
more valuable for finding Total Farm Solutions for every field.
Consider the following characteristics when selecting a team
of corn hybrids.
Genetic Diversity
Genetic diversity means planting a portfolio of hybrids
with a genetic makeup that includes as many of the different
genetic families for making hybrids as possible.
Genetic diversity increases the likelihood of growing
consistent-
yielding corn from one year to the next. The eight
main genetic families used to develop hybrids are classified
as Northern, Southern, Eastern, Western, Early Health,
Late Health, High Yield and Flint. The genetic families
originated with the first open pollinated corn varieties
developed years ago. Farmers used the earliest method of
plant breeding, called mass selection, to develop them.
Each year, farmers saved the best ears for seed to plant
next year’s crop. Genetics best for the particular locality
were selected. For instance, farmers in Ohio and Indiana
selected genetics that tolerate the saturated soils and
diseases found in the high-rainfall, eastern Corn Belt.
Corn plants needed thick rinds to make strong stalks
providing stalk quality for severe stalk rot environments.
Local farmers selecting for these traits developed the
Eastern Genetic Family. Likewise, farmers selected the
Northern Genetic Family for cool tolerance and the
Southern Genetic Family for heat tolerance. The Western
Genetic Family tolerates the drought conditions in the
drier production areas of Nebraska and South Dakota.
The high-yield environment of Iowa initiated the selection
for maximum yield potential called the High Yield Genetic
Family. The Early Health and Late Health Families
added disease resistance which allowed hybrids to stay
green and alive in the fall. Finally, Flints were used to add
test weight and cool tolerance. The strengths and weaknesses
of each genetic family are outlined in the table
that follows this discussion. There are other genetic
families not falling into the eight most frequently used
categories. They are lumped into one classification that
is called unrelated, as they are unrelated to the main
eight families.
Mass selection plant breeding methods used by early
corn farmers were only partially effective because corn is
cross-pollinated. The saved seed from corn plants having
the largest ear received only half its genetics from that
plant. The other half came from unidentified plants providing
the pollen. With the development of the hybridization
process, the genetics of both the female seed-bearing
plant and male pollen source can be controlled. This
enables plant breeders to combine several genetic families
into one hybrid containing the strengths of each family.
It provides the opportunity to correct weaknesses as
well. For instance, the maximum genetic yield potential of
the High Yield Family can be combined with disease tolerance
and stalk quality genetics of the Eastern Family making
high-yielding hybrids containing disease resistance and
stalk quality. The High Yield Family crossed with the
Northern Family develops high-yielding hybrids that
tolerate cool weather. Through the development of the
hybridization process, corn breeding became the art and
science of developing parent lines and hybrids combining
the strengths of different genetic families and minimizing
the weaknesses.
With hybrids being a combination of two parent lines,
and with plant breeders frequently combining two genetic
families into one parent line, hybrids can be a combination
of more than two genetic types and can exhibit characteristics
from all the types used. On the other hand, the
parent line can be selected to exhibit a particular trait of
one genetic type, with the remainder of the traits coming
from the other genetic family, even though the parent line
may be a combination of two families. In the descriptions
of hybrids, genetic backgrounds are given in notation
form. Capital letters indicate a strong percentage of a
genetic family, small letters indicate a lesser contribution.
When selecting corn hybrids, choose an assortment of
genetic families to provide a hedge against different
weather conditions. No genetic family is better than the
others. Each has different strengths, weaknesses and
weather preferences. Some tolerate cool, wet weather,
others hot and dry. Each family has strengths and
weaknesses regarding insect and disease tolerance,
soil type adaptability, plant population preference, test
weight, drydown, greensnap sensitivity and herbicide
injury susceptibility.
Genetic diversity increases the probability of achieving
consistent corn yields. Planting one genetic type risks the
entire crop if growing conditions expose a weakness.
Knowing the genetic type helps in making management
and placement decisions. For example, Eastern and
Northern types can be planted on poorly drained fields, but
Western types cannot. Southern types containing high-yield
genetics respond to aggressive nitrogen rates. Northern
types, with genes that code for enzyme systems that help
promote efficient grain-filling during typical northern growing
seasons, are recommended for cool wet localities. Your
agronomist is a great resource who’s there to help you in
making these crop management decisions.
When planting Bt corn and selecting conventional corn
hybrids for refuge acres, Western type genetics with high
native tolerance to corn borer are preferred. On the other
hand, Western types are therefore the least responsive to
Bt technology. Southern types tolerate sand best with
their large ear size and strong ear-flex, allowing for
reduced plant population as a hedge against drought.
Eastern types handle clay and saturated soils. This discussion
continues later, but the point is, knowing the
hybrid’s genetic type provides information to determine
which hybrids work where and if genetic diversity is
acceptable.
The hybrid description and rating charts in this seed
guide detail the genetic families used in making a hybrid.
The first letter(s) of the genetic family is the designator
(e.g., E = Eastern Genetic Family, HY= High Yield Genetic
Family). A strong contribution of a genetic family to a
hybrid is designated in upper case letters, while a smaller
contribution is designated by lower case.

| EASTERN GENETIC
FAMILY |
|
WESTERN GENETIC
FAMILY |
|
| Strengths |
Weaknesses |
Strengths |
Weaknesses |
| High Yield at High
Population |
Sensitivity to Heat |
High Yield |
Poor Rind Strength |
| Fast Silking |
Sensitivity to Drought |
Girthiness of Ear |
Cool Weather During Grain-fill |
| Girthiness of Ear |
Soft Kernel Texture |
Strong Silking |
Poor Roots |
| Disease Resistance |
Poor Test Weight |
Early Flowering Date |
Tight Husk and Slow Drydown |
| Gray Leaf Spot
Tolerance |
Tight Silk Channel and |
Strong Heat Tolerance |
Weed Problems Due to |
| |
Silkballing |
|
Short Height |
| Staygreen |
Sensitivity to Corn
Borer |
Excellent Drought Tolerance |
Silkballing |
| Rind Strength for
Stalk Quality |
Lack of Ear Length |
Strong Corn Borer Tolerance |
Sensitive to Wet Soils |
| Loose Husk at Maturity |
Eyespot |
Thick Shank for Ear Retention |
Poor Performance on Sand |
| Fast Drydown |
Late Flowering |
Strong Eyespot Tolerance |
Sensitive to Low Potash |
| Strong Emergence |
Poor Roots |
Gray Leaf Spot Tolerance |
|
| Rapid Grain-Fill |
Higher Ear Placement |
Strong Response to Potash |
|
| Performance on Clay |
Performance on Sand |
|
|
| |
|
|
|
| SOUTHERN GENETIC
FAMILY |
|
HIGH YIELD
FAMILY |
|
| Strengths |
Weaknesses |
Strengths |
Weaknesses |
| High Yield |
Poor Cold Tolerance |
High Yield |
Poor Cold Tolerance |
| Strong Heat Tolerance |
Sensitivity to Corn
Borer |
Large Girthy Ear |
Poor Seedling Vigor |
| Ear Length |
Poor Disease Tolerance |
Upright Leaf |
Slow Silking |
| Tolerance to Low
Population |
Poor Stalk Quality |
Strong Rind Strength |
Late Flowering |
| High Test Weight |
Poor Emergence |
|
Poor Disease
Resistance |
| Strong Performance on
Sand |
Late Flowering |
Low Test Weight |
| Response to High
Nitrogen |
Slow Silking |
Sensitive to Gray Leaf
Spot |
| |
Skinny Shank for Poor |
|
| |
Ear Retention |
| Sensitivity to Gray
Leaf Spot |
| Questionable Drought
Tolerance |
| Sensitivity to Low
Nitrogen |
 |
| Sensitive to wet soils |
| |
| |
| NORTHERN GENETIC
FAMILY |
|
| Strengths |
Weaknesses |
| Earliness |
Low Test Weight |
| Strong Cool Tolerance |
Weak Early Season
Growth |
| Rapid Grain-Fill |
Sensitivity to High
Heat |
| Strong Rind Strength |
Herbicide Sensitivity |
| Strong Staygreen |
Poor Roots |
| Excellent Eyespot
Tolerance |
Greensnap |
| Strong Germination |
Poor Yield at Low
Population |
| Strong Emergence |
High Sensitivity to
Gray |
| |
Leaf Spot |
| Strong Silking |
|
| Loose Husk for Fast
Drydown |
|
| Strong Performance on
Sand |
|
| and Clay |
|
| Good Tolerance to Low
Fertility |
|
| |
|
| LATE HEALTH
FAMILY |
|
EARLY PLANT HEALTH
|
|
|
Strengths |
Weaknesses |
Strengths |
Weaknesses |
| Ear Length |
Sensitive
to Corn Borer |
Early
Flowering |
Sensitivity
to Silkballing |
| Strong
Disease Resistance |
Low Yield |
Cool
Tolerance |
Low Yield |
| Excellent
Staygreen |
Poor Rind
Strength |
Strong
Seedling Vigor |
Poor Roots |
| Wide, Dark
Green Leaves |
Rust
Sensitivity |
High Test
Weight |
Tillering |
| Rapid Early
Season Growth |
Greensnap
Sensitivity |
Strong
Disease Resistance |
Sensitive
to Phenoxy |
| Test Weight |
Sensitive
to Smut |
Excellent
Staygreen |
Herbicides |
| |
|
Strong
Rust Tolerance |
|
| |
|
Tolerance
to Gray Leaf Spot |
|
| |
|
Adds Ear
Length |
|
| |
|
|
|
| FLINT FAMILY |
|
 |
|
Strengths |
Weaknesses |
| Strong Cool
Tolerance |
Low Yield |
| High Grain
Quality |
Slow
Drydown |
| High Test
Weight |
Poor Stalks |
|
Poor Roots |
|
|
Traits To Consider When Selecting A Corn Hybrid For A Particular Field
Seedling Vigor
Seedling vigor rating quantifies the ability of emerging
corn seedlings to grow vigorously early in the growing season,
especially if conditions are cool and wet. This is a
function of environment and genetics. Certain hybrids are
produced on female inbred lines possessing better genetics
for making seed with increased seedling vigor. Seed
produced during a year with favorable growing conditions
has better seedling vigor. Seedling vigor is lost when the
seed is exposed to frost or mechanical injury making seed
coat cracks through which seed rot pathogens can enter.
Use of Early Health and the Late Health Genetic
Families increases the seedling vigor and early season
growth of a hybrid. The Southern Genetic Family has the
greatest challenge with emergence, but can compensate
for reduced stands by forming larger ears on plants adjacent
to areas where plants fail to emerge. Northern genetic
types emerge well, but struggle with early season
growth during cool weather. The affected seedlings exhibit
purple stalks just above the soil surface caused by the
failure to translocate sugars to the roots. The lack of
early season growth in Northern types during cool weather
predisposes them to herbicide injury, especially with
growth-stimulating Phenoxy products such as Banvel.
Being the most sensitive to herbicide injury, the Northern
Genetic Family is the most responsive to herbicide tolerance
systems such as Roundup Ready, LibertyLink, and
Clearfield. The increased crop safety is of great benefit to
the Northern Genetic Family.
Another factor affecting seedling vigor is seed age.
When seed is returned after the planting season, or when
an overproduced hybrid is not sold, the carryover seed is
reprocessed and sold the next year, providing the quality
meets CROPLAN GENETICS standards. Seed corn carries
over well. However, when the seed becomes old, seedling
vigor is reduced, even when warm germination tests indicate
it is legal to sell. In general, flat seed sizes retain
seedling vigor better than rounds. This difference is not
observed in new crop seed corn production, but shows
up in carryover seed. CROPLAN GENETICS therefore
recommends medium flat seed for no-till.
Female inbred lines developed from the High Yield
Genetic Family have softer kernel texture and produce
seed that carries over from one year to the next better
than seed produced from harder-grained Late Health and
Early Health Families. The harder the seed coat, the better
the test weight, but also the greater the surface cracks
that may be incurred during harvesting and processing. Surface cracks allow the entry of pathogenic soil fungi which can kill the seed before emergence. In other words, improved seedling vigor but reduced test weight
are opposite sides of the same coin.
Plant Population
Each hybrid has an optimal plant population at which it
expresses its highest yield potential. The optimal plant
population varies from one hybrid to another based on ear
type. Consider ear type and its interaction with different
corn production systems before making a hybrid selection.
Ear Type
A hybrid has a fixed-ear type, a flex-ear type or somewhere
in between. A fixed-ear hybrid makes the same size
ear regardless of plant population. A flex-ear hybrid
makes either longer or girthier ears when interplant competition
is decreased by reducing population. Therefore,
a flex-ear hybrid has a competitive advantage when plant
populations are reduced by stress-related conditions such
as: planting in cool, wet soils; emerging in no-till systems;
and using lower populations as a drought control
mechanism.
The Southern Genetic Family has the greatest ability to
flex its ear size at low populations developing ears that
expand in length at reduced populations. Western and
High Yield genetic types stretch in diameter by increasing
kernel row number with decreasing populations. Eastern
and Northern types make consistent ear size at high populations,
but have little ability to increase ear size at low
populations. Therefore, Northern and Eastern types
require high populations to produce high yield. Conversely,
Southern, Western, and High Yield types make higher
yield at lower population by flexing ear size. There are
situations when ability to yield at lower populations
is strategic.
No-till: The stress of cooler soil temperatures and greater
soil surface residues at emergence in no-till causes a
loss in plant stand. Southern, Western, and High Yield
type flex-ear hybrids react to lower populations by forming
longer or girthier ears thereby retaining their yield potential. Hedge against drought:
Producers in the western Corn
Belt using lower plant population as a hedge against
drought, or producers farming sandier, drought-prone soil
types, can benefit from flex-ear genetics that develop larger
ears during above average rainfall seasons. Southern,
Western, and High Yield flex-ear hybrids respond to lower
populations by forming longer or girthier ears. However, as
mentioned in the section on drought tolerance, other
genetic families that have strong silking characteristics offer
excellent drought tolerance without lowering population.
Continuous corn: Stalk quality is a problem in
continuous
corn with insects and diseases overwintering on the
residue. Lowering the plant population reduces interplant
competition by producing shorter, fatter stalks, lower ear
placement and thicker stalk rind. These plant responses
to population reduction improve stalk quality. The flex-ear
type maintains high-end yield potential in spite of lower
population. Therefore, reducing the plant population of
Southern, Western and High Yield genetic types increases
tolerance to continuous corn by improving stalk quality, yet
retaining yield potential by flexing ear size.
Low fertility soils: Flex-ear hybrids planted at low populations
conserve the limited supply of soil nutrients for grain-fill. Fewer nutrients
utilized in producing the vegetative part of the corn plant lowers the total
nutrient requirement. Western and High Yield types planted at low populations
outperform hybrids developed from other genetic families in fields with low
fertility, especially low nitrogen. In the same way, the Western Genetic Family
produces shorter plants that require fewer nutrients for development. Western
Genetic type hybrids are therefore a key component of a high-acreage, low-input
crop production strategy, especially now with herbicide tolerance systems that
provide improved weed control in low leaf-area cropping systems. One outcome of
increasing plant population is a reduction in stalk quality. Increasing plant
population increases interplant competition. Corn plants respond to increasing
competition by growing taller plants with smaller stalk diameter. Increasing
population also elevates ear placement which increases stalk lodging. The
reduction in
stalk quality as plant population increases is especially
prevalent in Southern and Eastern types.
With the advantages of flex-ear hybrids, why are fixed ear
hybrids used? When planted at their optimal plant
populations, fixed-ear hybrids, with their tolerance to high
plant population, are the highest yielding. Northern and
Eastern genetic types, found in most fixed-ear hybrids,
have unusually strong silking characteristics and exceptional
uniformity of ear size at high plant densities. Strong
silking genetics are expressed by a hybrid prioritizing
the movement
of water directly to the silks at the time of pollination.
Silks are over 90 percent water. Pushing silks out
quickly ensures pollination and ear set, thereby driving
yield. During years with favorable emergence and growing
conditions, fixed-ear hybrids planted at high plant populations
are the test plot winners.
Fixed-ear hybrids tend to have shorter plant height. By
increasing plant population, they grow taller. Taller plants
increase yield potential by increasing leaf area. The high
population production strategy increases yield to the point
at which nutrient availability becomes limiting, necessitating
higher fertility levels. If planted at too low a population,
the reduced leaf area of the smaller plant wastes
sunlight striking the soil surface. Planting fixed-ear hybrids
at optimal plant population is essential to realize their
high yield potential. Planting fixed-ear hybrids at high
density requires the additional fertility to support the
extra plants. Plant Growth Type
Plant breeders follow two different strategies when
developing high-yielding hybrids of a given maturity. They
are 1) late tassel, short grain-fill and 2) early tassel, long
grain-fill. With one, plant breeders select hybrids using
longer periods of the growing season to build larger
stature corn plants. This large plant tassels late, filling
the grain rapidly with a large photosynthetic factory. This
includes the Eastern, Southern, High Yield and Late
Health genetic types. The opposite strategy selects
hybrids that build smaller plants, tasseling early and using
longer grain-filling periods to generate yield. Western,
Northern, Early Health and Flint are this type.
When planting late-maturing hybrids for the zone, or
when planting is delayed by a wet spring, early tassel,
long-fill types are more likely to mature and less likely to
produce low test weight grain. When planting is early, or
when planting an early maturing hybrid for the zone, the
late tassel, fast-fill hybrid takes advantage of higher leaf
area of larger corn plants
Stalk Quality
Stalk quality is defined as the ability of the plant to stand
intact through harvest after the grain-fill is completed and
the plant is dead. Stalk quality is an issue in the eastern
and southern United States where heat and high humidity
breed leaf disease and stalk rot which cause corn plants
to lodge. The two sources of stalk quality in corn are
thick stalk rind and staygreen. A hybrid with a thick rind
has excellent stalk quality. It is not the diameter of the
stalk, but the thickness of the outer rind that provides
resistance to lodging. The rind is made of lignin. Lignin
provides the rigidity that keeps the plant upright during the
harvest season. Lignin is resistant to attack by the saprophytic
soil-born organisms that cause stalk rot.
Developing high-lignin, thick-rinded corn plants through
plant breeding is easily done. However, the yield potential
of thick-rinded corn hybrids can be limited because nutrients
required for building thick rinds cannot contribute to
yield. A side note: Corn silage produced using hybrids
with thick rinds is low in feed quality because lignin is low
in digestibility.
For developing hybrids that have both high yield potential
and acceptable stalk quality, plant breeders select genetics
with late-season disease resistance that enable
hybrids to stay green and alive until the grain-fill is
completed.
Hybrids that are green and alive in the fall are
able to fight off stalk rot organisms that attack dead corn
plants. Corn plants that stay alive in the fall, after
grain-fill
is complete, continue producing plant nutrients. With
grain-fill complete, late-produced nutrients are sent to the
pith, the inner tissue of the stalk, which adds support to
the rind and assists in lodging resistance.
The Eastern, Early Health and Late Health Genetic
Families are the best sources of late-season plant health
and staygreen stalk quality. Eastern, Northern, and High
Yield Genetic Families are best sources of thick rind
strength. Hybrids containing the Northern/Eastern combinations
have the best total stalk quality. Southern and
Western genetic types have little rind strength and poor
staygreen, requiring complementary genetics in the hybrid
that contribute staygreen or rind strength before attaining
acceptable stalk quality. Placing Southern and Western
genetics on well-drained soils with adequate fertility keeps
them out of stalk rot-producing environments.
Plant breeders create test plot-winning hybrids by selecting
staygreen stalk quality that lasts through the harvest
season without giving up yield. However, this strategy
does not work in every situation. Staygreen fails to provide
resistance to stalk rot when the corn plant is prematurely
killed. For example, an early frost can kill the hybrid
before it matures. Then stalk rot pathogens can attack
the frozen and dead plant tissue.
Hybrids with thick rinds provide the best stalk quality
when stretching the maturity for the zone. Northern by
High Yield genetic types work best in case of early frost
or when heat units are below normal. However, during a
cool season, some of these hybrids may run into test
weight problems because they have a genetic predisposition
for low test weight.
Continuous corn is another challenge for staygreen
hybrids. Diseases and insects overwinter on corn residue
multiplying over years. When diseases and insects prematurely
kill the plant, stalk quality suffers. Improve
standability in continuous corn by planting hybrids that
produce thick rinds, such as those developed from
Northern and Eastern types. Another strategy for improving
stalk quality in continuous corn is planting hybrids with
increased ear-flex, allowing a reduction in plant population.
Lower population promotes shorter plant height, increased
rind thickness, and lower ear placement. Southern genetic
types, planted at low population, work on continuous corn,
but this type of hybrid also requires aggressive nitrogen.
Rotating hybrids in the same field from one year to the
next is strongly recommended for improving stalk quality.
Diseases and insects to which that hybrid is susceptible
develop during the first year. At planting in the second
year, every insect and disease to which that hybrid is
susceptible is present in the field from day one. Early
death, poor stalk quality, low grain yield and low test
weight follow.
Another limitation of staygreen occurs with low soil fertility.
During grain-fill, high-yielding hybrids require a large supply
of plant nutrients. If inadequate nutrients are available,
cannibalization of lower leaves and stalk for nutrients
occurs, and translocation of limiting nutrients to the grain
results. If nitrogen is limiting, interveinal chlorosis is
visible
in nitrogen-starved plants.
The movement of nitrogen from the stalk and leaves to
the grain causes the early death of the corn plant. Stalk
rot invades the dead plant causing it to fall down. It is
critical that high-yielding hybrids, dependent on staygreen
for stalk quality, be planted in fields with high fertility
levels
so nitrogen cannibalization and premature stalk death are
avoided. This is especially true of Southern and Late
Health genetic type hybrids.
Careful field scouting during the fall can alert you to
many stalk quality problems. Hybrids that stay green and
alive continue producing sugars after grain-fill is complete.
With the ear finished, these sugars move down into the
pith, improving stalk strength. When the sun shines on
stalks, sunlight reacts with sugars to produce a reddishpurple
pigment. Fields with plants turning reddish-purple
stand longer than fields dying quickly after black layer
development.
Drydown
Drydown is defined as the rate at which moisture leaves
the kernel after black layer. Factors influencing drydown
include: husk looseness, test weight, and staygreen.
Drydown is hastened in a hybrid with a husk that
loosens early, allowing air to dry the grain. Northern and
Eastern genetic types have looser husks. With husks loosening
one week earlier in September, warmer grain-drying
temperatures can make a dramatic difference in drying
expense compared to mechanical grain drying. Drydown is
slower in high test weight corn because it is more difficult
for moisture to leave high density grain with harder seed
coats. Northern, Eastern, and High Yield types have lower
test weight grain and therefore faster rates of drydown.
Low test weight and fast drydown frequently go hand in
hand as does high test weight and slow drydown.
Consider stalk quality and drydown together. Strong
staygreen makes it possible to gain four weeks of stalk
quality in exchange for giving up five days of grain drydown.
This is a favorable cost/benefit proposition.
Test Weight
Test weight measures the density of the grain. High density,
high test weight grain typically receives less physical
damage during harvest. High test weight grain is also
less likely to develop ear molds caused by delayed harvest
or heavy bird and insect feeding. Hybrids staying
green and alive in the fall have higher test weight than
fast-die, fast-dry hybrids because they have more time for
filling the grain. Southern, Early Health, Late Health and
Flint genetic types have the best test weight.
Yield And Hybrid Placement
Yield potential is extremely important in the production
of profitable corn. However, in hybrid placement strategies,
it must be considered along with stalk quality.
Hybrids that deposit a larger percentage of sugars and
starches into the grain have fewer nutrients remaining for
rind and pith development. Conversely, hybrids with large
stalks and thick rinds have fewer sugars and starches
remaining to produce high grain yields. For this reason,
plant breeders select high-yielding hybrids with enough
stalk size and rind strength to produce acceptable stalk
quality but rely on staygreen to keep the hybrid alive as
long as possible. As mentioned in the section on stalk
quality, staygreen is a good source of resistance to lodging,
but has limitations with regard to continuous corn, low
soil fertility and early frost potential. In these situations,
it
is wiser to plant hybrids with more rind strength and give
up some yield.
Corn Borer Tolerance
Hybrids differ in tolerance to corn borer for several reasons.
During reproduction, egg-laying moths are attracted
to the largest corn plants. Hybrids containing genes from
the Late Health genetic family have the characteristic of
growing rapidly early in the season, making them especially
attractive to egg-laying moths. Second generation corn
borers prefer the latest planted, most immature corn. The
Eastern genetic type takes the largest yield hit from second-
generation corn borer because they flower late for
their maturity and stay green late in the fall. For this reason,
Eastern types provide the highest financial return on
an investment in Bt technology. Southern type genetics
have unusually skinny shanks that quickly break when
invaded by corn borer causing dropped ears. Southern
types have a strong response to Bt with a large reduction
in dropped ears. Western genetics have the best native
tolerance to corn borer with the fattest shank attachment
aiding ear retention. They are the least responsive to Bt
but are the best choice for refugee acres.
Drought Tolerance
Many hybrids are selected for strong drought tolerance
even at high plant population. This is important in the
western Corn Belt where low plant population is used as a
hedge against drought. Low population strategy means
using only flex-ear type hybrids that provide good yields at
low plant populations: Southern, Western, and High Yield
genetic types.
Plant breeders have successfully selected for genetic
sources of drought tolerance that allow the planting of
higher yielding, fixed-ear hybrids in the western parts of
Iowa, Minnesota and into the Dakotas and Nebraska.
These hybrids prioritize moisture movement to the silks at
pollination, allowing for silking that is synchronized with
pollen shed. They are more likely to form ears during hot,
dry weather because they start with a well-pollinated ear.
Eastern, Northern and Western genetic types have strong
silking genetics. In the western drought-prone areas of
South Dakota and Nebraska, the Western genetic type
silks strongly and performs especially well. It tolerates
both heat and drought, and has a large flex ear that keeps
yield potential high at moderate population. Southern
genetic types are the slowest silking during dry weather.
Therefore, they should be planted at lower populations in
drought-prone areas to conserve moisture for the pollination
period. Southern types are the first to show unpollinated
tips when stressed during the flowering stage of
development due to longer ears and higher moisture
requirements for silk development.
By selecting hybrids that tassel and silk in synchrony,
even when it is dry, strong drought tolerance is obtained
without having to reduce population. This is a major
accomplishment by plant breeders in the quest for higher
yielding, more stress-tolerant hybrids.
Soil Types
Proper hybrid selection for a particular field cannot be
made without considering soil type. When planting on
heavy clay soils in high rainfall areas, saturated soil
conditions,
such as those found in northwest Ohio and eastern
Wisconsin, are often a problem. Northern and Eastern
genetic types show the highest tolerance to wet feet,
whereas Western and Southern types perform poorly
when soils are saturated. Corn growth and development
slows down on heavy soil types. Corn maturities need to
be conservative on these soils. On lighter soil types more
prone to drought, large ear types, such as Southern by
High Yield and Northern by High Yield, do well, whereas
Eastern types do poorly. Corn growth and development
speeds up on sandy soil types. Western types perform
poorly on saturated soils because they are sensitive to
wet feet. In addition, Western type hybrids tend to be
short, and moisture stress on sandy soils develops a
plant with too low an ear and too thin a leaf canopy that
can lead to weed control challenges. As a whole, most
Western style hybrids prefer the well-drained silt loam
type soils, though they do well on clay loams if tiled
and not saturated.
Fertility Levels
Southern type hybrids are nitrogen-driven. If the goal is
winning a yield trial, a Southern style hybrid placed on a
well-drained, high-fertility field with an aggressive nitrogen
program is the winning package. Eastern type genetics
planted at aggressive plant population are the next
choice. Western Genetic types are tolerant to lower nitrogen
when populations are adjusted down, but are sensitive
to low potassium and respond to high potassium.
Western genetics do well where native soil potassium
levels are high. In fact, high potassium levels in the plant
drive drought tolerance in Western types. Potassium is
important in plant water management because it regulates
the opening and closing of stomates. The Northern
by High Yield genetic type is tolerant to low fertility
because it flexes its ear, allowing for a reduction in plant
population. The robust plant type of Late Health genetics
responds well to the higher fertility levels required for
making the larger photosynthetic factory.
Herbicide Tolerance
There are many conventional herbicide products on the
market that perform well and have acceptable crop tolerance.
However, herbicide tolerant genes add value in several
special cases. The Northern genetic family has difficulty
establishing roots in cool soils. When stressed by
cool weather, Northern types struggle to translocate sugars
to the roots causing a purple coloration of the stalk above
the soil surface. The sugars are required for generating
new root growth. If sprayed with many herbicides at this
stage, injury can occur.
Northern and Early Health types are sensitive to growthstimulant
herbicides. These two genetic types are combined
together in many of the hybrids popular in northern
areas. For this reason, Roundup Ready, Clearfield, and
LibertyLink systems add value, because crop safety is
enhanced in genetic backgrounds having this sensitivity.
This is critical in northern areas where spraying under less
than optimal conditions frequently occurs due to cool,
wet weather.
Western genetics are short in plant height causing a
problem in the western Corn Belt where lower plant populations
are used. Decreasing population decreases interplant
competition and overall plant height. With the reduction
in leaf area comes a reduction in soil surface shading.
This lack of competition by the crop for sunlight increases
weed pressure. Roundup Ready, Clearfield, and Liberty-
Link production systems offer total postemergence weed
control solutions for late-season weed problems.
Genetic herbicide tolerance also has a special application
for no-till. With no soil tillage, Roundup Ready, Clearfield,
and Liberty Link production systems offer total postemergence
weed control solutions superior to most conventional
preplant systems. When combined with the right no-till
genetics, herbicide-tolerant gene systems enhance no-till.
With increasing fuel prices, the economics of no-till
increase simultaneously.
Maturity
In the past, planting an earlier maturing hybrid meant
sacrificing high-end yield potential. However, plant breeders
are increasing the yield potential of all maturities.
Maximum yield now is obtained by selecting the proper
maturity for the zone where planted.
The best maturity for any zone, in any year, maximizes
the available growing season. July, August, and the first
half of September have daylength, sunlight, and heat units
ideal for grain-fill. A hybrid black layering between
September 15th and 20th maximizes the grain-fill period
with time remaining for grain drydown.
Although it may be tempting to plant a maturity adapted
to an earlier or later zone, grain-fill, yield and stalk quality
are sacrificed. An earlier hybrid sacrifices yield as grain-fill
is completed while other hybrids are still filling grain. The
selection of later maturing hybrids sacrifices both yield
and drydown. Yields are reduced as daylight grows shorter
and heat units per day decrease during the later stages of
grain-fill. Drydown is sacrificed with the hybrid finishing
during the latter days of September and early October.
Observed maturities are strongly influenced by weather
and will display "normal" variation from year to year. It
makes no sense stretching maturity to get more yield, and
it makes no sense sacrificing yield to an earlier hybrid.
Select maturity adapted to the zone where it is planted.
"Team No-Till"
Selecting hybrids for no-till requires special attention,
because residue and lack of tillage slow warming and drying
of soil. Seedling vigor is a hybrid characteristic that
takes on greater importance in no-till. As seed ages into
its second and third year, medium flats retain seedling
vigor better than other grade sizes. Therefore, we recommend
medium flat seed for no-till, because age of seed is
unknown by the producer.
Delayed emergence from cooler, wetter, no-till soils
delays maturity. Therefore, mid-season maturing hybrids
for no-till are encouraged over full-season. Cooler
seedbeds and poorer soil-to-seed contact causes thinner
plant population in no-till. Flex-ear hybrids are therefore
recommended over fixed-ear hybrids.
Crop residue carries many corn diseases and insects to
the next crop. Therefore, the increased residue found in
no-till settings increases disease and insect pressure.
Hybrids with strong leaf disease resistance and staygreen
are required to fight off leaf diseases. Thick rinds provide
stalk quality if hybrids are killed prematurely by disease.
With the lack of tillage, weed control is challenging in
no-till. Roundup Ready, Clearfield, and LibertyLink production
systems offer total postemergence weed control solutions
superior to most conventional systems. In combination
with the right genetics, this offers another tool
for no-till.
In summary, the perfect no-till hybrid is one combining
the following characteristics: strong seedling vigor, flexear,
leaf disease resistance, staygreen, rind strength,
and herbicide tolerance.
|